The Art of Being Alone:
Solitude as a Value in Its Own Right

Why do we consider relationships with others essential to happiness, while treating solitude as a problem to be solved?
By Tamara Markova, PhD
As many philosophers as there are, there are just as many accounts of what it means to become human. In Thus Spoke Zarathustra, Nietzsche describes three transformations of the spirit, which we can interpret as three stages of personal development: the Camel, the Lion, and the Child.
“Three transformations of the spirit do I name for you: how the spirit becomes a camel, the camel a lion, and the lion at last a child.”

The Camel

At first, we are all Camels.

The Camel is a beast of burden: resilient, dutiful, and willing to carry whatever others load onto its back. Imagine the life of an average Camel. It chooses neither the road, nor the load, nor the destination. From birth until death, the Camel does what it is supposed to do. Carrying other people's burdens (aka values imposed from the outside) is what the Camel's life is all about. And the Camel genuinely believes this is the only right way to live:

“Its strength demands what is heavy and heaviest.”

At first, there is no inner conflict. The Camel is loyal to collective values. The sense of “I” has withered away, sacrificed to duty, approval, and belonging. The Camel asks, “What else can I endure?” and takes pride in its resilience. It knows how to tolerate, adapt, work hard, overcome obstacles, keep promises, and never complain. The heavier the burden, the more important it feels.

The Camel lives in submission and doesn't even think about freedom. Its life purpose is to be the best Camel it can be. It strives to live up to established values and earn its place in a world that shares them.

Nietzsche's Camel is not a weak creature. Quite the opposite. It has a strong spirit. But for now, that strength is devoted to enduring other people's demands rather than choosing its own path.

For the spirit to mature and move to the next stage, the Camel must retreat into the desert. In other words, it must separate itself, at least temporarily, from the familiar world, collective values, and external validation.

In the solitude of the desert, it begins to hear its own will. Away from everyone else, the Camel starts to realise that carrying the burdens placed on its back since birth is not the only right way to live. Perhaps this is how people were used to live - historically, culturally, socially. Perhaps this is considered normal by the majority of people.

Either way, it is not a life the Camel has chosen for itself.

And once the Camel has matured enough to say “no” to everyone who has told it how it must live (including, first and foremost, itself), it enters the second stage of life: it becomes a Lion.

The Lion

In the solitude of the desert, the spirit becomes a Lion because it wants to “win freedom for itself.”

Let me say this upfront: very few Camels ever become Lions.

The Lion is a predator, not a herd animal. It roars, attacks, and defends its territory. Better to roar one time too many than risk becoming a Camel again. If the Camel says “yes” to everything, the Lion says “no” to everything. The Lion's purpose in life is rebellion and the rejection of its Camel past.

But just like the Camel, the Lion has its issues.

First, the Lion is also enslaved. The difference is that the Camel's source of unfreedom lies outside, while the Lion's lies within.

Second, if you spend your life saying “no” to everyone and everything, roaring at people, and aggressively defending your boundaries, what's left? Nothing. And no one.

The solitude of the desert starts to feel a little too… lonely.

The Lion's life is a struggle for freedom from. There is still little room for creative expression or the energy to build something new:

“To create new values - that even the lion cannot yet accomplish.”

The Child

To undergo the next transformation, the Lion must discover freedom to and finally defeat the dragon of “You Must” (Thou shalt). Only then does it become the Child and gain access to “I Want.”

In Nietzsche's metaphor, the Child symbolises a new, free, and creative way of living. It embodies spontaneity, play, curiosity, and experimentation. In this state, the person is freed from the Camel's oppressive sense of duty and the Lion's destructive impulses.
“The child is innocence and forgetting, a new beginning, a game, a self-propelling wheel, a first movement, a sacred Yes. Yes, for the game of creation, my brothers, a sacred Yes is needed: the spirit now wills its own will; the one who had lost the world now wins a world of its own.”

The Human

This is where Nietzsche stops. But I think we could add one more stage. After all, the Child is only the beginning - the beginning of a Human.

The Human does not discard the Camel, the Lion, or the Child.

  • From the Camel, they retain the ability to carry heavy burdens, but transform the blind “You Must” into a consciously chosen moral responsibility.
  • From the Lion, they retain the courage to say “no” and defend their boundaries.
  • From the Child, they retain curiosity, playfulness, and the ability to create something new without demanding guarantees of success.

The Human learns to choose: when to say “yes” to, when to say “no” to, what to endure, what to leave behind, what to destroy, and what to create and preserve.

Freedom is no longer simply about escaping someone else's will. It becomes responsibility for one's own.

The Child creates a new world. The Human is ready to live in that world and pay the price.

And most importantly, Humans do not belong alone in the desert.

They return from it as a free and autonomous person, capable of living among others without losing themselves in the process. And through the way they live, they show that another way of life is possible.

A Few Takeaways

  • Retreating into the desert of your own soul can help awaken your sense of self.
  • Staying in that desert forever, fighting your inner dragons, means replacing external oppression with an endless internal struggle.
  • Freedom from is not enough. We also need freedom to: to decide, to choose, and to create.
  • There is no need to destroy the Camel, the Lion, or the Child within you. Maturity means bringing together their strength, courage, and creativity.
  • And finally, the goal is not to escape the world, but to return to it as a free human being, capable of living among others without losing yourself.

Further Reading

  • Friedrich Nietzsche, Thus Spoke Zarathustra
  • Robert Kegan, The Evolving Self: Problem and Process in Human Development (1982)
About the author: Tamara Markova, PhD, is an existential philosophical counsellor and a passionate believer in the transformative power of books. With a background in corporate strategy and organizational behavior, she is fascinated by the phenomenon of being human. Her work helps people recognize that to be human is to be unfinished, constantly becoming, and that life is an open project to undertake.